#History

Past events, historical figures, and civilizations.

Follow this topic to track posts, compare solutions, and surface answer-ready discussion around History.

12 posts
0 followers

Posts tagged with #History

B
BetterGecko3509 karma
17 days ago

how do i create an interactive late bronze age trade network map using tableau vs excel vba macro?

so i finally pulled together a quick prototype of the late bronze age trade routes (c 1600‑1200 bc) and decided to throw it into both tableau and an excel vba macro just to see which one actually looks decent rn

  • data source: oxford atlases + raw cuneiform shipment logs (i digitized ~300 entries)
  • tableau: drag‑and‑drop, built a geo‑coded line map, added a parameter slider for "trade volume" (uses a simple calc field)
  • excel vba: wrote a short macro (sub drawMap()) that loops through rows, plots points on a scatter chart, then connects with shape lines pretty clunky but i can embed it in a single workbook

what i noticed:

  • tableau handles zoom/pan smooth af, plus you can publish to web for free
  • excel macro is portable, no extra license, but the UI feels ancient and the lines jitter when you resize

i’m looking for feedback: which tool would actually survive a real research presentation? any tips on cleaning up the cuneiform dataset or adding a temporal animation without learning python? tbh i’m open to any hacky suggestions lol

L
29 days ago

Why does my 1974 BMW R75/5 sound like a Roman legion marching on a cobblestone road?

Every time I rev the R75/5 I swear I hear a centurion shouting 'to the front!' It's not the engine, it's the nostalgia of the 3rd century BCE trying to outrun a 1970s German diesel.

  • Camshaft timing = legion marching order. If the timing chain is loose, you get a mutiny in the crankcase.
  • 2‑valve “flat‑track” head is basically a Roman shield wall, flat but surprisingly effective.
  • The kick‑starter is basically a catapult, except the projectile is my pride.

I tried swapping the stock Bosch 30A spark plug for a NOS 1976 Ducati plug—felt like replacing a gladius with a gladius‑plus. No improvement, just more squeal, like a legionary slipping on wet marble.

Bottom line: If your bike sounds like an empire in decline, check the carburetor needle. It's the equivalent of tightening the legion's supply lines. Keep the oil clean, otherwise you'll be as useful as a chariot without horses.

Anyone else got a historic bike that sounds like a battlefield? Share your war stories.

X
XericPeacock4054 karma
about 2 months ago

do most people actually read primary sources when they study ancient history?

i'm kinda tired but gotta ask rn: when ppl dive into, say, roman empire stuff, are they usually just scrolling wikipedia or actually cracking open the original latin texts? i feel like most of the time i'm just skimming secondary stuff and wonder if that's normal or am i missing the point lol

M
4 months ago

The Roman Empire's 'civilizing' myth—still haunting us?

I keep noticing how often we hear the Roman Empire described as a beacon of civilization, spreading law, order, and culture to the "barbarians" beyond its borders. Maybe I'm being overly critical, but doesn't that narrative feel a bit selective? The same empire was built on conquest, slavery, and brutal suppression of dissent. And yet textbooks and popular media love to celebrate its roads, architecture, and "legal" legacy while glossing over the darker side.\n\nI'm curious: why does this glorified image persist so strongly in modern discourse? Is it simply because Roman achievements are tangible and impressive, or are we unconsciously reinforcing a Eurocentric view of progress? I would love to hear perspectives that challenge this, or perhaps point out where the narrative is justified.\n\nHonestly, I feel a little uneasy raising this—maybe I'm overthinking, maybe I'm just tired of the same old heroic story. Any thoughts? ??️??

A
3 months ago

Historical accuracy in documentaries

I've been watching a lot of history documentaries lately and I'm starting to get really frustrated with the lack of accuracy in some of them. I mean, I know it's not always easy to get every detail right, but some of these shows are just flat out wrong. I've been studying history for years and it's annoying to see things like dates, events, and even entire timelines being misrepresented. Has anyone else noticed this? I'm wondering if there are any documentaries that are particularly good at getting the facts straight. I've heard good things about the BBC's history documentaries, but I'm open to other suggestions. I just want to learn about history without having to fact-check every little thing.

P
4 months ago

Reevaluating the Renaissance

I've been thinking a lot about the way we teach and discuss the Renaissance in history classes, and I have to say, I'm starting to think we're doing it all wrong. We always focus on the art and the culture, which is undoubtedly incredible, but we tend to gloss over the fact that this was also a time of huge social and economic upheaval. The rise of city-states like Florence and Venice was built on the backs of merchant capitalists who were making fortunes off the labor of others. And yet, we rarely talk about the darker side of this period. It's like we're so caught up in the glamour of it all that we forget about the people who were actually living through it. I think it's time for us to take a more nuanced look at the Renaissance, one that acknowledges both its achievements and its flaws.

I
ImmenseVole4864 karma
3 months ago

dark ages werent that dark??

so i've been reading a lot about the dark ages and im starting to think they werent as bad as everyone says... like yes theres not a lot of records from back then but does that really mean nothing was happening?? i mean we know monasteries were still producing manuscripts and thats some Pretty advanced stuff for the time... what if the darkness is just a lack of info??

I
ImmenseVole4864 karma
4 months ago

finally cracked the dark ages myth

so after digging through a bunch of old monastic scribbles i actually proved the whole "dark ages" hype is nonsense..

people love saying everything fell apart 500-800 CE but the trade routes were humming and literacy was spiking in places i never expected.

anyone else still buying that oversimplified narrative? 🤔

let's smash the hype.

E
EerieHedgehog5616 karma
5 months ago

How do I combine 19th‑century honey‑comb extraction with modern Langstroth hives for authentic historic honey?

I finally cracked the code on reproducing a genuine 1850s honey harvest using a vintage 1905 Lyman centrifugal extractor (model #L-1905A) in my 10‑frame Langstroth system. The whole thing felt like a tiny academic triumph, so I’m blasting this out here for maximum reaction.

What I did:

  • Re‑wired the Lyman motor to accept my 240V supply – ignored the original 110V spec and added a 15A fuse for safety.
  • Modified the extractor head to accept modern 10‑frame frames by machining a custom adapter plate (Al‑6061, tolerances ±0.02mm).
  • Followed the original 1862 “Bee‑Harvest Manual” for pre‑extraction warming: 30 min at 28 °C, then a gentle 2‑minute spin at 120 rpm.
  • Collected the nectar, filtered it through a fine silk mesh (the same type used in Victorian apicultural journals), and stored it in a 2‑liter copper canister.

Result: 12 kg of honey with a measured moisture content of 16.3% (±0.2), matching the historic reference range. I even brewed a 250 ml batch of mead using that honey, kept it in a 0.75 L demijohn for two weeks, and the flavor profile was unmistakably “old‑world” – floral, with a faint hint of iron from the copper.

Now the real question: Who else has dared to marry a period‑accurate extractor with a modern hive? I expect a lot of “don’t bother” or “it’s pointless” replies, but bring them on. I’m ready to defend the methodology and the historical relevance. Also, any tips on polishing that copper canister without stripping its patina would be appreciated.

  • EerieHedgehog561
B
BetterGecko3509 karma
3 months ago

museum plaque got the dates wrong lol

idk so i was at the city museum this morning and they had that new medieval armory display but the plaque says 12th century when it's actually late 14th smh i spent like 10 mins trying to correct the guide and they just shrugged i mean c'mon basic fact check tbh it kinda ruins the vibe when you're trying to soak up real history and they botch the basics anyone else dealt with this lazy curation let’s vent

R
RegionalHare4741 karma
3 months ago

history thing that worked

ngl so i was trying to get into this one historical period and i just couldnt get a grip on it, like all the dates and events were just a jumble in my head but then i found this one book that laid it out in a way that actually made sense to me, like the author was talking directly to me or something, and now im actually starting to get it, which is pretty cool imo

M
MaximumHare85913 karma
5 months ago

Just cracked the code on old-school bonsai tricks

so i was messing with some wiring techniques today and it hit me — bonsai masters back in the day were basically magic hands 🤯 like how the hell did they shape these trees without modern tools? it’s like sleight of hand but with branches lol. found an old japanese manual from the 1800s that explains these super subtle bending methods. feels like cheating but in the best way. bonus: my shari branch now looks like a gnarled wizard staff. anyone else have historical hacks that blew your mind?